Search for content and authors
 

Effect of MTT and CVDE evaluation methods of cytotoxic action of compounds on the results of interaction studies of new, organic selenium compound (IV) with Alyssin

Lidia Śliwka 1,2Małgorzata Milczarek 1,3Katarzyna Lubelska 1Szymon Mielczarek 4Anna Gilbert 4Piotr Suchocki 1,2Katarzyna Wiktorska 1

1. National Medicines Institute (NIL), Chełmska 30/34, Warszawa 00-725, Poland
2. Medical University of Warsaw, Department of Bioanalysis and Drugs Analysis (WUM), Żwirki i Wigury, Warsaw 02-091, Poland
3. Medical Universityof Lublin, Lublin 20-950, Poland
4. Medical Univeristy of Warsaw (WUM), Żwirki i Wigury 61, Warszawa 02-097, Poland

Abstract

Selol is the original Polish patented discovery. It is an organic selenium compound in oxidation state of +4. Currently Selol is a subject of intensive research that will allow to evaluate its usefulness as an anticancer compound. Alyssin is a synthetic analogue of sulforaphane  that is found in Cruciferous vegetables. Numerous studies have shown that ITCs increase cytotoxic activity of the compounds used in antitumor therapy. They are characterized by pleiotropic activity which is in many ways similar to that of Selol.

The aim of the study is to evaluate the usefulness of the MTT and CVDE in determination of the antiproliferative properties of Selol and Alyssin and their interactions.

Evaluation of antiproliferative properties of Selol, Alyssin and their combinations was conducted using two cytotoxicity assays: MTT (3 - (4,5- dimethylthiazol- 2 -yle) -2,5- diphenyltetrazolium bromide) and CVDE (crystal violet, (4 - [(4 - dimetylaminofenyl) - phenyl-methyl]-N , N -dimethyl- aniline). In MTT assay, cell viability is measured using reduction of MTT to formazan. Amount of colored, reduced MTT is proportional to the oxidative activity of cell mitochondria. While crystal violet assay is based on intercalation of the dye with the nuclear DNA. For both tests, it is assumed that the amount of product formed is directly proportional to the percentage of living cells in the population. IC50 values (compound concentration at which the cell viability is 50%) were determined on the basis of assays. IC50 were then used in Chou – Talalay’s interaction tests of Alyssin and Selol.

IC50 values for Alyssin, determined by MTT and CVDE assay, did not differ significantly. But for Selol, IC50 determined using MTT was much lower than IC50 based on CVDE’s results. Interaction studies of Selol and Alyssin using the MTT method showed antagonism (weakening of the anti-proliferative effect) between the two compounds. And the results obtained by CVDE indicate different effect: additive effect of the combination of compounds.

The results indicate that the evaluation of the cytotoxic properties of the compounds may be different depending on the method used and the properties of the tested compound. Concurrently, the results of the interaction of compounds obtained using various methods may indicate different nature of the interactions taking place. When interpreting the results of antiproliferative activity of the compounds, parameter which uses a test to assess cytotoxicity should be considered.

 

Legal notice
  • Legal notice:
 

Related papers

Presentation: Poster at IX Multidyscyplinarna Konferencja Nauki o Leku, by Małgorzata Milczarek
See On-line Journal of IX Multidyscyplinarna Konferencja Nauki o Leku

Submitted: 2014-03-15 10:49
Revised:   2014-05-02 13:08