Search for content and authors
 

Hate Networks Revisited: Observations of Gazeta Wyborcza discussion forum 2009-2011

Paweł Sobkowicz 1Antoni Sobkowicz 2

1. Nie afiliowany, Warszawa 02-777, Poland
2. Warsaw University of Technology, Faculty of Mechatronics, Św. Andrzeja Boboli 8, Warszawa 05-525, Poland

Abstract

We present an analysis of the properties of a social network, formed by users participating in one of the most popular Polish political discussion forums, gathered at three periods within a two year time, during which events that significantly increased the already strong political division of the Polish society occurred. We find that despite communication is motivated by controversy and negative emotions, the resulting social network is remarkably similar to networks formed in discussion boards based on similarity of views; showing power-law like behavior of user popularity and activity. All collected messages have been analyzed to determine their content type, author's political sympathies and emotion level. An automatic emotion recognition algorithm is presented, giving results closely corresponding to human evaluations. Using the data on reader evaluation of the comments we present estimates of the political sympathies of the `silent majority' of forum readers. The data from the observations are used as the input for an agent based computer simulation model, reproducing many observed characteristics of the forum. We observe a remarkable stability of individual political support. Extensive discussions among the forum users did not lead to changes in their political affiliations or specific opinions. In contrast, emotions expressed by the forum users, mainly negative, were found to vary from post to post and between the discussion threads. We show that differences in a user interface between the two alternative forum Web pages, especially effects of features promoting direct one-to-one communication, have significant impact on message content and decrease negative emotions. Implications of such changes on promoting communication across a political divide are discussed.

 

Legal notice
  • Legal notice:
 

Related papers

Presentation: Oral at 6 Ogólnopolskie Sympozjum "Fizyka w Ekonomii i Naukach Społecznych", by Paweł Sobkowicz
See On-line Journal of 6 Ogólnopolskie Sympozjum "Fizyka w Ekonomii i Naukach Społecznych"

Submitted: 2011-12-26 10:39
Revised:   2011-12-26 10:39